How Air Ambulances (Don't) Work

  Peržiūros 743,894

Wendover Productions

Prieš 3 mėnesius

Sign up for the Curiosity Stream/Nebula bundle deal at it's lowest sale price ever (less than $1 a month) at CuriosityStream.com/Wendover
Listen to Extremities at ExtremitiesPodcast.com
Buy a Wendover Productions t-shirt: standard.tv/collections/wendover-productions/products/wendover-productions-shirt
Subscribe to Half as Interesting (The other channel from Wendover Productions): ltlost.info
LTlost: www.LTlost.com/WendoverProductions
Instagram: sam.from.wendover
Twitter: www.Twitter.com/WendoverPro
Sponsorship Enquiries: wendover@standard.tv
Other emails: sam@wendover.productions
Reddit: Reddit.com/r/WendoverProductions
Writing by Sam Denby
Research by Sam Denby and Tristan Purdy
Editing by Alexander Williard
Animation by Josh Sherrington
Sound by Graham Haerther
Thumbnail by Simon Buckmaster
Select footage courtesy the AP Archive and Amazon
References
[1] www.umms.org/ummc/health-services/shock-trauma/about/history
[2] www.nature.com/articles/s41591-020-1059-1
[3] onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/epdf/10.1111/j.1553-2712.2001.tb00201.x
[4] www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0196064487801749; pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10155402/; pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12957978/; pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12217471/; pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19783323/; pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22418825/; www.researchgate.net/publication/6563423_Are_pre-hospital_time_and_emergency_department_disposition_time_useful_process_indicators_for_trauma_care_in_Italy
[5] www.amtrauma.org/page/traumalevels
[6] www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1402347/
[7] healthcostinstitute.org/emergency-room/air-ambulances-10-year-trends-in-costs-and-use
[8] www.gao.gov/assets/690/686167.pdf
[9] onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1468-0009.12464
[10] www.nytimes.com/2015/05/06/business/rescued-by-an-air-ambulance-but-stunned-at-the-sky-high-bill.html?searchResultPosition=9
[11] verticalmag.com/features/surprise-medical-bills-ban-could-reshape-air-ambulance-industry/
[12] www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK78049/
Musicbed SyncID:
MB01A23UAUIMVCW

Komentarai
Will Scanlon
Will Scanlon Prieš 9 val
USA healthcare system is unacceptable. We’re the laughing stock of the world.
hiding
hiding Prieš 2 dienas
alterative title: Episode #56 on why the US is a failing country
hiding
hiding Prieš 2 dienas
20:11, debt doesn't transfer downwards like that, if its their spouse thats one thing (and there is legal ways to get out of that debt) but if your parent dies, you are in no way responsible for their debt, if anyone tells you differently they are wrong/ trying to scam you
hiding
hiding Prieš 2 dienas
SO basically if you were "saved" by an air ambulance, you need to fake your own death and start a new life since that would actually be cheaper alterative you can just not pay it (they cant arrest you for debt that's healthcare-related) but that's always a risk either way, don't pay it, if few people pay it they will eventually look to governments help to stay aloft and then they can be regulated
Mango
Mango Prieš 2 dienas
Hai
akselj2
akselj2 Prieš 2 dienas
Wendover, this is USA-specific. The Rega (Swiss Air Ambulance) is definitely among the best. There was a case where they flew a taiwanese woman from London back to Taiwan with no costs. Seriously, you should've mentioned this is seriously USA.
Flint 25
Flint 25 Prieš 3 dienas
2:58 damn that T-Mobile coverage map is impressive.
2prize
2prize Prieš 4 dienas
*laughs in free healthcare*
Isolation
Isolation Prieš 4 dienas
Here in Australia Air ambulance's are free in most states. States, where it's not free, will charge you no more than $1200 AUD, ground ambulances are $600-$1,000 ish AUD and 99% of medical treatment at hospitals including major, moderate and basic surgeries, visits to the ER, and going to the doctors is free.
AJdeMan
AJdeMan Prieš 6 dienų
Thanks for the investment tip
MineWit
MineWit Prieš 7 dienų
Even if the golden hour principle is false, Blood loss still can be affected by time, more liters of blood could be lost. Almost everywhere in medicine, it screams "faster = better", because it is. Diagnosis, treatment, hell, even vaccinations account for this. They won't need an air ambulance, but others do.
Tazhie Nunurbusinezz
Tazhie Nunurbusinezz Prieš 9 dienų
I live in a town of 2,700 in a county of 10,000. There is a hospital here & it has a community funded chopper (free to patients) to get people to larger, more specialized hospitals & trauma centers. We can also purchase a roundtrip $100 ticket on the private jet owned by one of the large private owned companies in the county to get to the nearest metro if it isn't an emergency situation. We can purchase these tickets for any reason really but if someone with a medical appointment wants the same seat, you can get bumped to a different day. It's why the tickets are super cheap for executive level travel. We also have community grants for hospital bills. I've had mine completely forgiven twice.
green1
green1 Prieš 10 dienų
Where I live, Air ambulance cost to patient: $0. In fact it's actually cheaper here to use an air ambulance than a ground one. The ground one will charge $385. The helicopter will charge nothing. For this, the government pays $7.2 million per year to cover 3 full time helicopters from 3 different bases hundreds of km apart. Last year that covered 1325 flights. Total cost to the patients: 0, cost to the government: $5434/flight (to be fair, operating the air ambulances does cost more than that, but the non-profit organization running the service also fundraises through donations and running a lottery. Their total budget for the year was about 4 times the government contribution) The dollars quoted here are also worth less than the US dollar.
Säbelzahnmöwe
Säbelzahnmöwe Prieš 11 dienų
I watched this video on Nebula. I was so shocked by what i heard, that i had to come here and comment on how shocking this is. The American system really is truly broken. I mean, dont geht me wrong, Germany is not a total paradise, but wow, this puts things into perspective.
Melissa Johnson
Melissa Johnson Prieš 12 dienų
My advice as someone who has worked in billing for a air medical company....if you are conscious, don't agree to air transport. Which is easy because most of the time you are not given a option. Don't sign anything and don't pay the bill when it comes. After a while they will either A) settle for a far cheaper amount or B) they will take you to court to have your wages garnished. That sounds scary BUT go to the court date. Argue that you never agreed to or was given the chance to deny the air transport service. You were never told of pricing or you were never of sound mound during the time to make that decision (like given narcotic pain medication or sedation). The majority of the time, IF YOU FIGHT IT, the company is forced to settle the debt for pennies on the dollar or forced to write the debt off and be unable to collect.
Ek Flex
Ek Flex Prieš 10 dienų
👍
Daeus Millan
Daeus Millan Prieš 14 dienų
overtriage happened to me 2 years ago and im still paying the helicopter bill
Andy Neal
Andy Neal Prieš 14 dienų
That's you're problems. COST. IF IT'S LIKE UK where hospitals are paid by taxes & the helicopters are funded by donations. That equals to saving life over money.
Jonathon Greenhow
Jonathon Greenhow Prieš 14 dienų
You need to caveat that *some of this is very focused on US healthcare and a normal patient in most other countries would not worry about the cost of said air ambulance trips
Tim S
Tim S Prieš 16 dienų
We have that in Switzerland 🇨🇭it‘s called REGA
RoboFarmer
RoboFarmer Prieš 17 dienų
I’d love to see a similar video but focused on the UK or any European country... I’m not sure if this is true but I think it’s only London’s air ambulance service that isn’t completely funded by charity. As in London’s is maybe helped by the government.
Andreas la Roi
Andreas la Roi Prieš 17 dienų
Here in Switzerland most Air Ambulances are run by a non-profit foundation of which 40% of the population are patrons (~44 USD a year). The Rega does alpine rescues as well. Patrons don't have to pay rescue flights when they're not covered by insurance. The Rega was established in 1952.
Vaughn Ferrara
Vaughn Ferrara Prieš 17 dienų
Did he push 2 different videos together? The first and second half are talking about two different things. You could have just said helicopters are overcharging and here is why.
J S
J S Prieš 18 dienų
Rural hospitals DONT have trauma centers. So saying closing rural hospitals is a problem isn't true
Jyot Hathi
Jyot Hathi Prieš 20 dienų
Wait, I was browsing LTlost. How did I stumbled upon Netflix?
Patrik
Patrik Prieš 21 dieną
"Unprofitable rural hospitals" As a Swede, I am unfamiliar with this concept. Please enlighten me.
Steven Mitchell
Steven Mitchell Prieš 22 dienas
I am alive because of an air ambulances fast response. Thanks to God, and that CareFlite crew.
shepherd
shepherd Prieš 23 dienas
I'm a firefighter in rural canada, to our nearest trauma center is 50 minutes.by road (lights and siren's) add time to package them up or cut them out of their car plus the time up to 20 minutes to get on scene. In canada air ambulances are more of a mobile ER as they are staffed with a doctor pilot and copilot so they can get doctors to the accident to start administering care before they even leave the scene. I think the issue is the USA and how it is managed sorry...
Ben Mannette
Ben Mannette Prieš 27 dienų
13:25 it's almost as if. . . The free market shouldn't be involved here.
Thunder Spirits
Thunder Spirits Prieš 27 dienų
I don't get it. If I am unconscious then I cannot give my consent to be air-lifted which also mean no one can force me to pay their massive bill, right? I mean, do I even have the right to refuse to be transported via air ambulance? or at least choose the transportation method/provider?
Alesson Delmiro
Alesson Delmiro Prieš 27 dienų
🇧🇷[Laughs in free healthcare system]
rundErd frech
rundErd frech Prieš 27 dienų
In every halfway welfare country: How can we safe his life? USA: How can we make profite? Lets exploit him. This has nothing to do with grace of charity, equality or human rights. It's the ugliest side of capitalism. Now you can make hundreds of excuses and explanations but I ask you, would you accept this explanations from a system you hate too, e.g. communism, North Korea? Change the system.
Pace119
Pace119 Prieš 28 dienų
I loathe these types of videos because only one side of the argument is made. The case against the government is always hidden. While I agree with much of this video, only half the story is told from a clear biased position. First, it was Congress who deregulated the airlines. The narrator even mentioned at 14:24 how that helped the airline industry in the US over the last 40 years. It is Congress' fault for creating a great airline industry while creating a poor air ambulance industry at the same time. Second, as a former elected official, our city's private ground ambulance service failed and had to be run by the local government a little over a decade ago. Again, this was due to Congress. Ground ambulance service is used disproportionally by elderly people as are small, rural hospitals. The vast majority are on Medicare. Medicare is in essence socialized medicine. It doesn't matter what the ambulance charges the federal government for a particular service. They could bill $1 billion for the ambulance ride, but they will get back a flat rate fee depending on the health care provided during the ambulance ride. With 40% of air ambulance service being hospital to hospital transportation, I'm assuming similar demographic trends for those services too. However, air ambulances may have a more diverse age range for services from auto accidents or other medical issues to the hospital. Medicaid for poor people is very similar to Medicare for the elderly. The feds pay back only a flat rate for services. Back in the 80's & 90's when the government was more fiscally sound, having an ambulance service was a great entrepreneurial business to get into. Unfortunately, federal government reimbursement rates have not kept up with the inflationary cost of healthcare. When my city’s private ambulance service failed, it was the last private one in the state still operating. Third, is the recuperation rate of ambulance services not provided by the federal government. If 96/100 people die anyway with or without the air ambulance, how much does the ambulance service get from a deceased person's estate? How much do life insurance companies pay after death? I'm sure a life insurance company has much better lawyers to negotiate rates for an ambulance ride than a private citizen. The insurance companies are in business to make money too. They don't just write $50,000 checks willy-nilly to any ambulance company. Instead, they raise everyone else's life insurance rates at best. In the event someone does pull through, I assume a lawyer to negotiate a settlement of less than $50,000 is cheaper than any bill the ambulance company sends. While most people live paycheck to paycheck and don’t have thousands of dollars saved for such an emergency, their GoFundMe campaigns probably are not paying the full amount billed. What the ambulance service really wants is a very wealthy person (or estate in death) to use their service with no outside insurance who can write a big, fat check to cover other patients when the ambulance company didn't get the full amount. Those people probably don't exist, because most wealthy people are over insured as opposed to under insured. Finally, as a frequent medical user who MUST be on Obamacare, socialized medicine is horrific. I already pay about one-third of my income just for health insurance every year. In many states, people already pay half or more of their income in federal, state, and local taxes. How much more do Americans want to pay in taxes for that free ambulance ride? With the baby boomer generation well into retirement, entitlement programs like Medicare and Medicaid becoming insolvent, and declining birth rates around the world; this problem is not going to be fixed by throwing more tax money at it. Until elected officials at the state and federal levels start working together instead of calling each other names like children, we are all out of luck no matter what side of this issue you hold. The private equity firms are just taking advantage of government's ineptness and weaknesses.
Stefano Pessina
Stefano Pessina Prieš 28 dienų
Well this was depressing
Dardenelle Green
Dardenelle Green Prieš 29 dienų
The entire American healthcare system is a pyramid scheme. A giant parasitical apparatus set up by fat cat billionaires set up to milk every last dime out of sick and dying people.
Jiwoo Park
Jiwoo Park Prieš mėn
"You can't pay the bill?" " *no* " "Then I'm gonna take back your new thing" just a joke
alli herr
alli herr Prieš mėn
This is EXTREMELY dependant on the injury. As an EMT watching this, I have a lot to say about the faster being better and reasons why patients are taken to level 1 centers more. For example, if we know the patient is having a heart attack or complicated cardiology issue, we are going to send them to a place with a cath lab. These are usually only found in level 1 trauma centers. We wouldnt take them to a lesser hospital without the resources to treat them. Also, ambulances are usually private companies, just like everything else. My company provides flight services. People shop around and compare prices all the time. And yes, since medicare happened insurances don't cover flights anymore. Medics make the call to flight someone usually, and we don't fly unless we need to. Also, non profit vs profit isn't a fair comparison. One recives donations to cover funds, the other has to make profit. The 4 out of 100 thing makes no sense. Are you kidding me? Are you advocating for people to just die and that would be better? There are a few truths in here but they are very hidden with nuanced topics and rough conclusions based on strange stats.
Mr. Leininger
Mr. Leininger Prieš mėn
You intentionally confuse economic harm with medical harm when you state that doctors violate their oath when they use an air ambulance, because only 4 of 100 are saved. Even if this rate were insignificant, the cost of care is obviously not in the scope of the oath. You also go populist and slam private equity funds for their market power, as if it is unconscionable to use it in a health care market. I do feel that the fact that the consumer is in a fight for their life makes it a bit unsavory, however. Think from the fund's perspective; it is just another good business that offers attractive ROI for their investors. And these investors are diverse: individuals, pension funds, endowments. And they're all cheering the management who had the foresight to invest in the right companies.
Mr. Leininger
Mr. Leininger Prieš mėn
You clearly don't know what a market failure is, yet you state with such confidence that it is synonymous with a deviation from a competitive market, which is untrue. A market failure occurs when demand and supply agents do not execute exchanges. A market where any price is incurred is not a failure since exchanges are occurring. Clearly, it's a strange market since a doctor is a proxy demand agent, but it's not a failed one. I suppose you have consumer sensibilities that are biased towards the efficient markets hypothesis, since you inexplicably state that the price is 'too high'. However, prices are only experimental outputs of the market. Would you complain if a chemical reaction produced a molecule you didn't like? As long as exchanges are occurring, then prices have been 'discovered', and no market failure exists. It makes no difference if a doctor is responsible for the demand.
Freedom HQ
Freedom HQ Prieš mėn
Why not just make the hospitals pay out of pocket for helicopter fairs ? If patients or insurance companies are billed without their knowledge or informed approval they have a right to sue. Insurance company’s should be able negotiate the price of the actual bill of the ride in addition to medicare from there. And maybe, through a small court of appeals, the insurance company can argue the price of a fair ? The argument must allow for there to be a justified amount for the air fair that caps off at a common market price plus evidence based adjustments for the actual investment made by the individual helicopter company. Through this court of appeals, an unbiased jury will decide if the fair makes sense or if it was in truth a predatory practice. In this way the government does not decide the air fair but instead, the wisdom of an informed common people do. If anything, if current prices are realistic and said price is to be billed by the hospital. Then Ultimately the Insurance company should take the hit and not the patient. They can raise their rates, but with proper limits on contractual agreements, a patient should eventually have every opportunity to leave that company and to move onto a better and more economical one. Thats just an idea and Im probably wrong. Yet, I believe there is still something we can do about the medical industry as a nation that does not turn the medical industry into a purely public sector like other countries. Capitalism for the win baby.
Daniel Takawi
Daniel Takawi Prieš mėn
"These 702 words..." nice touch :)
Joe Orange
Joe Orange Prieš mėn
It's fucking wild how much it cost, my girlfriend had an allergic reaction to the vaccine yesterday and the bill for the ER was $700 and they gave a 10% discount for paying the same day you are there, and now we wait for the X ray bill and the blood work bill, and maybe even the EpiPen that was given at the vaccine site to stop the anaphylactic shock It's fucked up how often there is a genuine question to risk your pocket book or risk your life, usually risking your life is the more common one
Jai Singh
Jai Singh Prieš mėn
More videos exposing the medical industy please. It's run like a mafia in the US.
Caleb Di Biase
Caleb Di Biase Prieš mėn
As an Aussie, I love free healthcare, but I do believe that paid healthcare is worth it, just not the overcharging, if healthcare is going to be a business then they should have competition to keep the price down. It is really sad that there are large companies that will still take advantage of the helpless who get no other choice if they want to live
Brandon B
Brandon B Prieš mėn
It's not a "symptom of market failure". It is, like so many things, a 'symptom of government failure' . Oh Murica; Serving as the Vanguard for Western Society's March into the gaping maw of Capitalism, since 1917! 🥇
peppe2994
peppe2994 Prieš mėn
Dear USA friends, here on the other side of the atlantic ocean, we always discuss about several things regarding USA, and your healtcare system is one of the main topic. We are all sincerely angry when hearing about tremendous inequity regarding health, life of people, and costs for cares. I wish you that something cound change. For whos don't know how healthcare system works in Europe: all it's completely free (unless something unnecessary), and all means all, medicines, surgery, air ambulances and even transfers beetween far hospitals hoperated by the air force.
iron 13
iron 13 Prieš mėn
Nationalize them by force.
TheseYeahThese
TheseYeahThese Prieš mėn
Love your fucking videos
sasha mellon
sasha mellon Prieš mėn
It’s time the USA nationalised its health service and funded it through tax. Imagine being a burns victim and not being able to get treatment as you don’t have insurance. Just monsterous!!
Brandon Marvel
Brandon Marvel Prieš mėn
once again saying profit should not be an incentive to healthcare!!! it is such a glaring conflict of interest Jesus I hope at some point we fix the health system for real and our grandchildren will we are crazy if we tell them it was actually this bad.
Brandon Marvel
Brandon Marvel Prieš mėn
why is it we close hospitals non profitable hospitals in rural areas but keep post office open... so in America getting daily mail service is more of a right than... living...
Edwin
Edwin Prieš mėn
I cant wait for your video on masks, cause sooo much of this could apply to masks...
ErierCandy
ErierCandy Prieš mėn
They worked in Vietnam.
Lazlow Rave
Lazlow Rave Prieš mėn
This is pretty sad. Kinda looked up to the pilots of air ambulances as rock stars. Kinda shattering that visual.
Jamzan
Jamzan Prieš mėn
11:10 oh yeah I forgot we were talking about america
Luis von Randow
Luis von Randow Prieš mėn
it's almost as if healthcare shouldn't be a market.
HorrisNorris
HorrisNorris Prieš mėn
So glad I don't live in the USA
Jesse Graas
Jesse Graas Prieš mėn
I'm still over $30,000 in debt for my sky pirate bill. The car accident was not my fault in any way.
Porto Alex
Porto Alex Prieš mėn
So I must be pretty lucky, thankful and have no complaints as in my country in cass you need a helicopter to transfer you on a better equipped hospital is free. The same applies to search & rescue missions like finding a lost person on a mountain or a stupid surfer who decides to get on the sea even there's a prohibition of such activities by the authorities due to extreme weather conditions...
givingus5
givingus5 Prieš mėn
Just too clarify as an EMT the golden hour does make a difference for stoke patients. Those studies did not cover that. As long as they can be taken to a high level stroke center. This assumes the person had a major stroke. The comment below by Abel F. sums it up very well. I agree with the rest of you on the cost and not to encourage the bad behavior as many you mentioned already. Stroke centers.... getaheadofstroke.org/stroke-center-designations/#:~:text=Similar%20to%20how%20patients%20are,complete%20stroke%20system%20of%20care.
Eve Adams
Eve Adams Prieš mėn
American here, drowning in debt for several ambulance rides I took over a decade ago, one of which was across a parking lot to another wing of the hospital. $950 for that one. And I was perfectly ambulatory. I will never be able to repay them all. I think I'm gonna have my DNR tattooed on my back like in Mad Max: FR.
OhWhale
OhWhale Prieš mėn
I wonder if this happens in Canada? 🤔
K R
K R Prieš mėn
Disgusting American health care system.
Eastmarch2
Eastmarch2 Prieš mėn
14:40 what flag is that? It has far too few stars to be an American flag.
Berkan
Berkan Prieš mėn
Why do American Ambulances look so cheap, old and Janky.
Raymond LG
Raymond LG Prieš mėn
I alway enjoy how the heavy Patriotic Muricas defend the failed healthcare system US has. Because in true pragmatics terms there is really no way, shape, form, argument etc to state otherwise in favor of such horrific cash cow system. The answers I usually and always get is the look at third world countries ones! Yeah that's true! But them countries don't have the GPD budged that US does.
JumpHit
JumpHit Prieš mėn
Yeah, come have a look at england's air ambulance. American air ambulances are trash.
Trey DeJesus
Trey DeJesus Prieš mėn
Just shows the problem isn’t capitalism it’s a lack of capitalism. This industry has no competition, that means it’s not capitalism. In this case yes, setting price ceilings would be a good thing, and it’s crazy this hasn’t been fixed. Government intervention is usually bad, but in this case bad is better than worse. A failed market that exploits people with no competition should always be stopped.
CautiousDavid
CautiousDavid Prieš mėn
This video hits hard :(
Xander Anderson
Xander Anderson Prieš mėn
The UK (and others) air ambulance system is better for a number of reasons. 1 being they are charities that work with the NHS so are free and are paid for the same as any charity: through donations. Another is the UK is MUCH smaller than the US so you can get to a major trauma center quicker.
Maciej Dolny
Maciej Dolny Prieš mėn
Hi Wendover, if you are making video specifically about USA problem, just put the "in USA" in the title. It's only 5 letters. You makes people confused. Greetings from Poland.
Nootushya Quaternion434Jabberwocky
Nootushya Quaternion434Jabberwocky Prieš 2 mėnesius
After seeing this, I'm so glad that air ambulance is operated by charities in my area.
Poggers guy
Poggers guy Prieš 2 mėnesius
Upload on your other channel more
Pro Vax
Pro Vax Prieš 2 mėnesius
A few commentators still defend the US system as it provides choice. Outside USA, including U.K., private medical is still available but most people, comparing the two, opt for the public system.
Ram Rachum
Ram Rachum Prieš 2 mėnesius
Your videos have great content, but the way you speak makes it very difficult for me to listen. I don't know why so many people who make educational videos have to speak with an intonation like an alien robot. Do you feel it would be less interesting if you just spoke normally, the way you speak to a friend?
Tianrang Bu
Tianrang Bu Prieš 2 mėnesius
The recipe for every Wendover video: half interesting and half blatant US-centrism
Maria Dąbrowska
Maria Dąbrowska Prieš 2 mėnesius
Wow. That was powerful. I really am glad that I am not an American.
David Tran
David Tran Prieš 2 mėnesius
Sure would be nice to be able to carry a card around indicating my choice to ever use an air ambulance if unconscious. I would say no every time. I'd rather die than pay $50,000 to some person who is already rich. Sure, call me dumb, but know that my sacrifice means potentially lower, more competitive fees for you if you ever use an air ambulance down the road.
3ICE
3ICE Prieš 2 mėnesius
On top of that, an annual CuriosityStream subscription is 26% off right now, meaning a year of two great streaming sites combined is about the same cost of one fancy burger.
Kai Hyena
Kai Hyena Prieš 2 mėnesius
Wendover slowly becoming a breadtuber lol
Chad Johnson
Chad Johnson Prieš 2 mėnesius
While I tend to agree with most statements in this video, there's a larger issue at hand. If taxpayers are to foot the bill for these services, then that would mean somebody making $10k a year can go cliff diving in rural Utah, take their Instagram/TikTok photos/clips, break a few of their limbs, get a $15k chopper ride to the hospital with another $10k surgery, and walk out the front doors, and do it all over again. Meanwhile, I'm just playing COD on my computer, making $xxx,000 per year, putting myself at significantly less risk than the Instagram-hype junky, and I have to continuously pay for his/her dangerous & negligent life-style. Same with smokers, or obese people, or drug-addicts, and so on... There does need to be profit-ceilings on certain parts of the medical industry, but socializing medicine, especially in the U.S. where people treat their bodies like rental cars, is just not a sustainable way to fix these issues.
john pardon
john pardon Prieš 2 mėnesius
basically. america hates poor people.
Airbus A320-214
Airbus A320-214 Prieš 2 mėnesius
Well, the study shown in 6:23 does consider the "higher numbers of preclinical measures [in Germany]" to be far more relevant than a fixed amount of time. However, one has to consider that emergency physicians in Germany often arrive by special cars only transporting them or helicopters. In both cases a timely advantage is given.
「CELLO KID」
「CELLO KID」 Prieš 2 mėnesius
I didn't know what a traumatic injury was, googled it and now I probably won't be able to sleep for the next week
Dillon
Dillon Prieš 2 mėnesius
id say pass an ammendment to the deregulation act excluding any air vehicle that is used for medical transport. lol granted that wont happen the goverment is soooooo corrupt in lining their pockets it will take somthing massively bad to THEM to actually change anything in a reasonable ammount of time granted what bad that is could just be their family members getting this fee or this or that and slowly changing their opinions on it because yea.. im blessed my local area uses a hospital purchases helicopter. and that due to my income i lie on i get goverment coverage for my health... because that should be a basic human right and i should not have to lie on my income to get that :/ yes i pay taxes but not what i should because of the simple fact if i did i would also pay atleast 600$ a month in coverage insurance.
Mike Kelly
Mike Kelly Prieš 2 mėnesius
Thank goodness I live in the UK with a National Health Service that is by no means perfect but a lot better than the American system!!!!!!!
Joseph Chu
Joseph Chu Prieš 2 mėnesius
basically every time he says right???? : ME: NO no no no no no
Adouble
Adouble Prieš 2 mėnesius
I'm from the U.S. and I didn't even know that this B.S was going on...
Thu Truong
Thu Truong Prieš 2 mėnesius
The interesting shade reciprocally wave because tugboat wessely cover beneath a combative unshielded. painful, toothsome picture
IIsatomi3ii
IIsatomi3ii Prieš 2 mėnesius
Im sick of living in the US with the chance 3-5 years of my 12k yearly income can go out the window because of a drunk driver. Or a freak accident.
Jon Nupe
Jon Nupe Prieš 2 mėnesius
Ok, so all we have to do is destroy all helicopter ambulances in a regular basis
starbomber
starbomber Prieš 2 mėnesius
Your videos make me sad
Just This Guy
Just This Guy Prieš 2 mėnesius
In short, air ambulances work, the problem is how much they cost.
Warlord M
Warlord M Prieš 2 mėnesius
I'm sorry but this is really irresponsible. You've been getting more extreme the bigger you've gotten, but this crosses a line. Saying that a doctor is violating their Hippocratic Oath by making a medical decision that costs their patient money is totally incorrect and unreasonable. I understand you are mad that the financial systems around healthcare in the United States are a travesty, but taking it out on doctors is not only totally wrong for anyone to do, but for someone in your position, with the power to inform and to influence the opinion of millions of members of the public, it is unethical. This video is bad, and you should take it down, fix it, and put it back up so that people can learn about the important issues you raise without coming to believe your poorly reasoned opinions and lies disguised as opinions are facts.
Warlord M
Warlord M Prieš 2 mėnesius
@Imrunningforpope they aren't violating their oath. Financial costs aren't medical harm. And even if he didn't mean for it to sound that way, it does, and that's just as bad
Imrunningforpope
Imrunningforpope Prieš 2 mėnesius
How can you watch this video and believe he is criticizing doctors? He is saying they are FORCED to violate their Hippocratic Oath.
James Dinius
James Dinius Prieš 2 mėnesius
So basically a very useful and important to the consumer act was passed and a bunch of vultures exploited it. This is why laws need to be written very carefully. I support free markets in 99% of cases, but this is a clear market and regulatory failure and these monsters need to be stopped.
James Dinius
James Dinius Prieš 2 mėnesius
To everyone saying this is an example of the failure of the US medical system you are missing a key point. This is a failure of the AVIATION INDUSTRY not the medical industry. It's an aviation regulation that causes this. Dosn't mean there shouldn't be legal changes, but there is literally nothing the medical industry can do beyond lobbying for that change.
KopaZ
KopaZ Prieš 2 mėnesius
5:15 What if I shoot the author of this paper 2 times to the back twice, but - 1) I leave him to bleed out for about 50 minutes, then taxi him to hospital using helicopter which say, takes about 20 minute to get to operating table. 2) I toss him to helicopter ASAP and put him on surgery which takes 20 minutes. I wonder what scenario would be better for this person?
Dopp
Dopp Prieš 2 mėnesius
The problem is not really the market, it's that they can charge you for something they've done without consent, it should really be a public service so this isn't a problem ffs
fat pig 789
fat pig 789 Prieš 2 mėnesius
Air ambulances dont work in America. Alot of things do not work in America like their railway and their measuring system
Joseph Park
Joseph Park Prieš 2 mėnesius
Imagine being in a helicopter accident only to be immediately carried by another helicopter.
Shane Powell
Shane Powell Prieš 2 mėnesius
the three studies you cited, one you did not cite the remainder of the quote " The time factor involved in managing and transporting hypotensive penetrating injury victims directly to a regional trauma center does not appear to be related to an adverse outcome, at least during the first hour after injury. second did not refute the golden hour it just moved the goalpost. third did not even mention the golden hour, it just mentioned an 8 minute window. couldn't you have chosen better examples of your claim?
Why Helicopter Airlines Failed
13:11
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 1,3mln
The UK's Failed Experiment in Rail Privatization
20:28
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 756tūkst.
World's Fastest Workers!
9:00
Beast Reacts
Peržiūros 9mln
TRUE Limits Of Humanity - The Final Border We Will Never Cross
11:41
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
Peržiūros 5mln
How Amazon's Super-Complex Shipping System Works
18:50
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 1,5mln
The US' Overseas Military Base Strategy
14:06
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 3,1mln
How to Beat the Casino, and How They'll Stop You
14:12
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 1,6mln
The Electric Vehicle Charging Problem
19:50
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 1,8mln
The Insane Logistics of Formula 1
09:14
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 4,4mln
Egypt's Dam Problem: The Geopolitics of the Nile
17:06
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 1,3mln
How China Broke the World's Recycling
19:38
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 2mln
How to Design Impenetrable Airport Security
14:18
Wendover Productions
Peržiūros 4,2mln
World's Fastest Workers!
9:00
Beast Reacts
Peržiūros 9mln
TRUE Limits Of Humanity - The Final Border We Will Never Cross
11:41
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
Peržiūros 5mln
TRUE Limits Of Humanity - The Final Border We Will Never Cross
11:41
Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell
Peržiūros 5mln
Chad on Mars - SNL
3:20
Saturday Night Live
Peržiūros 5mln
Face To Face With Floyd Mayweather
14:07
Logan Paul
Peržiūros 6mln